Skip to content
Flag of Manitoba Labour Help Manitoba

When to File a Claim

An Employment Standards claim is free to file, doesn’t require a lawyer, and can lead to recovered wages, vacation pay, overtime, or termination pay. But it’s not the right first move for everyone or every situation.

File a Claim When

Section titled “File a Claim When”

The most common, well-supported reasons to file:

  • Your employer expects you to work on your time off without compensation , working through stat holidays without premium pay or a substitute day, working through “vacation,” answering required calls/emails on personal time without pay.
  • Your employer expects you to work overtime without paying for it, unpaid hours past 8/day or 40/week, off-the-clock work, banked time that never appears, or a misapplied “manager” exemption.
  • Your employer terminates your employment without cause and without severance, no notice, no pay in lieu, just “today is your last day.”
  • Your employer terminates your employment claiming cause, but the cause doesn’t actually meet the legal threshold, performance grumbles being used as cover for an unjust dismissal.
  • You quit because of constructive dismissal, see Constructive dismissal. Quitting in this context is treated as a termination by the employer.
  • Unpaid wages, vacation pay, or final pay, anything owed that the employer hasn’t paid out.

Try Negotiation First When You Can

Section titled “Try Negotiation First When You Can”

A claim should be the last resort, not the first one. Where you’ve still got a working relationship, or where the employer is open to a direct conversation about what’s owed, negotiation is faster and less stressful.

Even after termination, a polite-but-firm written request for what’s owed, with the implicit understanding that you know your rights and are willing to escalate, can resolve a lot. An employment lawyer’s letter often accelerates that further.

Timing Rules to Know

Section titled “Timing Rules to Know”
  • Current employees can file an Employment Standards claim. Most don’t, for understandable reasons (see Reservations and hesitations). A claim can also be withdrawn by the employee at any time, which some current employees use as a pressure tactic during negotiation.
  • Former employees have 6 months from the end of employment to file a claim under the code. If you wait longer than that, you may lose the ability to recover through Employment Standards even if you have a strong case.
  • The 6-month window does not extend automatically while you negotiate. If you’ve been in talks with a former employer for several months, the clock has been running.

When a Lawyer Is the Better Path

Section titled “When a Lawyer Is the Better Path”

Employment Standards is excellent for statutory entitlements, the minimums set by the code: unpaid wages, vacation, overtime, statutory notice, etc.

It is not the right venue for:

  • Common-law reasonable notice that exceeds the statutory minimum (often the larger amount in a termination case)
  • Damages for the way you were terminated, bad-faith termination, serious mental distress, defamation
  • Most discrimination claims, those go to the Manitoba Human Rights Commission

If your situation involves any of these, talk to an employment lawyer before filing. Filing a claim doesn’t preclude a lawsuit, but signing a settlement through Employment Standards usually does.

Next

Section titled “Next”